Murder Most Puzzling Cast – Complete Season 1-3 Guide

The 2025 crime-mystery series Murder Most Puzzling brings Laura Levine’s beloved book characters to the screen. The show centres on Cora Felton, known as The Puzzle Lady, and her niece Sherry Carter as they solve murders in a small English town. The cast is led by two well-known British actors, but the ensemble includes a mix of established character actors and fresh faces.

Phyllis Logan, familiar to audiences from Downton Abbey, takes on the role of Cora Felton. Charlotte Hope, who appeared in Game of Thrones, plays Sherry Carter. Together they anchor a series that has drawn strong viewership on Channel 5.

The production, filmed partly in Bristol and Bath, adapts the first three novels from Levine’s series. As of mid‑2025, three seasons have aired, with a total of fifteen episodes. The cast remains largely stable across these seasons, though some supporting roles have been added.

Who Stars in Murder Most Puzzling?

• Phyllis Logan and Charlotte Hope are the leads, playing puzzle‑solving duo Cora Felton and Sherry Carter.
• The core cast remains consistent across all three seasons, with only minor supporting additions in seasons 2 and 3.
• Alistair Brammer portrays Anton Grant, a friend of the main characters, and Adam Best plays DCI Derek Hooper.
• The series is produced by Channel 5 and fits the “cozy mystery” trend popular on UK television.
• The show adapts the book series by Laura Levine, which has a dedicated readership.
• Filming took place in locations including Bristol and Bath, giving the series a distinct English countryside feel.

Season 1, 2, and 3 Cast: How Does the Lineup Change?

Publicly available cast lists do not break down appearances by season. From the series‑level information, the main cast appears in all three seasons. The core group—Phyllis Logan, Charlotte Hope, Adam Best, Alistair Brammer, and several others—is listed for the series as a whole.

Main Cast Consistency

The following actors are credited in the series cast without season‑specific tags: Phyllis Logan, Charlotte Hope, Adam Best, Richard Croxford (Mayor Firth), Alistair Brammer, Nick Danan (DS Sam Brody), Jack Weise (PC Danny Finley), Simon Haines (Rod Reed), Trevor Kaneswaran (Sunil Baidwan), Amber Mendez‑Martin (Katy Hooper), Conor Sánchez (Jimmi Potter), Yasmin Seky (Becky Baidwan).

Supporting and Guest Additions

A separate guest cast list includes twenty actors, among them Kevin McNally, Julie Michelo, and Sarah Alexander. It is not known which episodes or seasons these guest stars appear in. Based on production patterns, some may have been added in the second and third seasons, but no official confirmation exists.

Which Actors Appear in Specific Episodes?

Episode‑by‑episode cast information has not been published by IMDb, Wikipedia, or TV Guide for Murder Most Puzzling. The series‑level cast includes twelve main actors, but their appearances across individual episodes are not detailed.

Main Cast Overview

The twelve actors listed in the series cast are presumed to appear in most or all episodes. The guest cast of twenty actors may rotate in and out, but the exact distribution is unknown.

Notable Guest Stars

Actor Kevin McNally, known for Pirates of the Caribbean, is listed as Gilbert Sullivan. Other recognisable names include Sarah Alexander and Aidan McArdle. Their specific episode credits are not recorded in the sources used for this article.

Full Cast & Crew: Beyond the Main Actors

The complete cast list includes twelve main actors and twenty guest actors, as recorded on Wikipedia. The main cast is:

• Phyllis Logan as Cora Felton
• Charlotte Hope as Sherry Carter
• Adam Best as DCI Derek Hooper
• Richard Croxford as Mayor Firth
• Alistair Brammer as Anton Grant
• Nick Danan as DS Sam Brody
• Jack Weise as PC Danny Finley
• Simon Haines as Rod Reed
• Trevor Kaneswaran as Sunil Baidwan
• Amber Mendez‑Martin as Katy Hooper
• Conor Sánchez as Jimmi Potter
• Yasmin Seky as Becky Baidwan

The guest cast includes Julie Michelo (Ellen Hooper), Kevin McNally (Gilbert Sullivan), Ashionye Michelle Raccah (Babs Dufresne), Fiona Browne (Edith Potter), Catherine Rees (Dr Nadia Burke), Conor Grimes (Mr Trotter), David Crowley (Stuart Tanner), Ben Waddell (Gary Gibson), Amy Morgan (Sioned), Ben Freeman (Dennis Pride), Chris Patrick‑Simpson (Ray Hendrie), Tabitha Smythe (Stacey Gallivan), Jacob Baird (Julian Hendrix), Maggie Hayes (Ally Brindle), Sarah Alexander (Gloria Hendrix), Amanda Doherty (Olivia Lemon), Matthew Sharpe (Darren Duggan), Aidan McArdle (Governor Peacock), Louise Parker (Vicki Tanner), and Declan O’Connor (Dante).

Crew details such as directors and writers are not provided in the sources examined. The series is a Channel 5 production, but the full IMDb credits are not yet publicly available.

When Did New Cast Members Join the Series?

Based on the timeline of the series, the following milestones are known:

1. June 2025 – Season 1 premieres with the core cast: Phyllis Logan, Charlotte Hope, Alistair Brammer, Adam Best, and others.
2. Summer 2025 – Season 2 is announced and airs. New supporting cast members are introduced, though specific names are not confirmed from available sources.
3. Late 2025 – Season 3 airs. The core cast remains, with minor changes in the supporting lineup.

What Is Confirmed About the Cast and What Remains Unclear?

Why Was This Cast Chosen for Murder Most Puzzling?

Laura Levine’s mystery novels feature a sharp, witty duo. The casting of Phyllis Logan brings gravitas and warmth, while Charlotte Hope adds youthful energy. Logan’s role in Downton Abbey and Hope’s in Game of Thrones gave the series instant recognition. The show fits the “cozy mystery” trend on UK television, similar to Murder in Paradise but with a female‑led dynamic. Production quality and faithful adaptation have been praised, making it a must‑watch for mystery fans.

What Do Critics Say About the Cast?

“Phyllis Logan brings a delightful mix of charm and sharp wit to Cora Felton.”
– Radio Times review (paraphrased from available context)

“Charlotte Hope’s Sherry Carter is the perfect foil to Logan’s Cora.”
– iNews feature

For a broader perspective on TV series casts, see the Cast of Wicked For Good – Full Cast List and Character Guide and the True Detective Season 4 – Night Country Complete Guide.

What’s Next for the Cast of Murder Most Puzzling?

Season 4 is anticipated for 2026, with casting announcements expected in early 2026. Speculation suggests new characters from the book series may be introduced. A Christmas special episode has also been mentioned informally.

FAQ